Top Aide To RI Gov. Raimondo To Lead EOHHS; Policy Director For Providence Mayor To Run HHS

By Gina Macris

RI Governor Gina Raimondo has named Eric Beane, the top aide tasked with fixing the UHIP computer disaster, as Executive Secretary of Health and Human Services. 

Courtney Hawkins, chief policy officer for Providence Mayor Jorge Elorza, will become the new Director of the Department of Human Services (DHS). And Zach Sherman, Director of HealthSource RI, will take over the day-to-day management of the UHIP turnaround, according to a statement from Raimondo’s office issued May 12.

“Rhode islanders deserve and demand high-quality public services. I am confident the new leadership for our Health Cabinet will ensure better access to care and better outcomes for Rhode Islanders,” Raimondo said.

There has been a nearly complete turnover in the human services leadership since the start of the year, primarily because of problems with the UHIP computer system and with the management of the Department of Children, Youth and Families.

Beane has been with Raimondo since she took office in 2015, serving first as deputy chief of staff and then as chief operations officer, before the governor put him in charge of running DHS and turning around the $364-million Unified Health Infrastructure Project (UHIP) in January.

Hawkins, a Rhode Island native, “brings more than 15 years of experience working with social service agencies and in public policy” here and elsewhere, Raimondo said.

Hawkins has a bachelor’s degree from the University of Rhode Island and a master’s degree in social work from Columbia University. Before returning to Rhode Island in 2015, she worked as senior vice president at the now-bankrupt FEGS Health and Human Services, one of the largest social service agencies in New York City. The agency closed its doors in 2015.

UHIP, the largest information technology project ever undertaken by the state, has delayed eligibility decisions and healthcare and social service benefits for tens of thousands of Rhode Islanders – including some with developmental disabilities - since it was launched in September, 2016.

The botched rollout also cost the jobs of former EOHHS Secretary Elizabeth Roberts, the state’s chief digital officer, Thom Guertin, and the former DHS director, Melba Depena Affigne. 

In announcing the new appointments, Raimondo’s office said that Anya Radar Wallack, Acting Secretary of EOHHS since February, will return to the Brown University School of Public Health in June.

Beane is to start his new duties June 1 and Hawkins will take office June 12. Both appointments require confirmation by the state Senate.

RI Gov Appoints Wallack HHS Secretary; Wood To Continue to Lead DD Effort; UHIP Woes Continue

By Gina Macris

The Rhode Island Department of Human Services has begun re-hiring - months after it laid off about 70 workers in conjunction with the roll-out of a dysfunctional automated benefits system – to help Rhode Islanders who face hardships from delays and denials caused by the broken computer system.

That is but one step going forward that Governor Raimondo announced at a media briefing Wednesday, Feb. 15, when she released a scathing report on the Unified Healthcare Infrastructure Project, or UHIP, compiled by Eric Beane, the acting director of the DHS and her chief operating officer.

Blaming the vendor, Deloitte, for delivering a “defective system,” Raimondo also warned that it will take 60 to 70 days to stop the backlog in applications from growing and about a year to fix the system.  Beane’s report, completed over the last thirty days, showed the problem was much worse than she had previously believed, the Governor said. 

She apologized to Rhode Islanders for a situation she said was “unacceptable, inexcusable, and intolerable.”  

She introduced Anya Radar Wallack as the new Secretary of Health and Human Services  (HHS). Wallack formerly served as Medicaid director and the director of the state’s health insurance exchange under the Affordable Care Act.

Elizabeth Roberts, who had made a career of health care reform as a state senator, lieutenant governor and HHS secretary, submitted her resignation Wednesday. Raimondo accepted it, she said, because she agreed with Roberts that the problem needed a “fresh set of eyes.”

 Roberts had taken the stance that the system could be fixed quickly, despite the glitches, but Beane’sunvarnished analysis showed that not to be the case, Raimondo said. 

As Roberts’ long-time deputy, Jennifer Wood had been heavily involved in trying to fix the troubled UHIP rollout. Wood, who has served both as Deputy Secretary and General Counsel of HHS, will continue as General Counsel and will remain in charge of the state’s efforts to comply with the 2014 federal consent decree mandating integration of daytime services for adults with developmental disabilities, according to Beane.

Among thousands who have suffered hardships from the UHIP fiasco are individuals with developmental disabilities applying for adult services from the Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH).

Last September, just as BHDDH solved an eligibility backlog in applications, many of them from young adults leaving high school, the introduction of UHIP caused months-long delays in the release of the money necessary to actually pay for approved services. In December, there were an estimated 100 young adults who had services delayed or expected services to be delayed as a result of the UHIP snafu, according to one informal report from the Rhode Island Parent Information Network.

Timely service is an issue of concern to an independent court monitor in the enforcement of a 2014 federal consent decree requiring community-based developmental disability services.

At the press conference, Beane said the backlog in all types of applications will continue to grow unless there is a “staffing surge to address the timelines.”

Beane’s report said Deloitte assured the state the computer system was ready to go live when it was not.

Raimondo said the state continues to withhold tens of millions of dollars (about $68 million of a $364 million project)  and is re-negotiating its contract with Deloitte. “It’s tense,” she said.  But she emphasized that UHIP can be fixed.

Raimondo said she has come to realize that the state needs to have more high-level officials with the technical expertise to analyze a vendor's claims and call out mistakes. In general, the public sector has been lacking in that regard, she said.

There had been warnings from federal officials that the computer system was not ready for a state-wide roll out, but human services officials decided against a try-out period.

Former DHS director Melba Depena Affigne and her chief digital officer Thom Guertin resigned in January under pressure from Raimondo. 

Click here to read Beane's report

Roberts Resigns as RI Health and Human Services Secretary; Wood's Future Role Unclear

By Gina Macris 

Rhode Island’s Secretary of Health and Human Services, Elizabeth Roberts, resigned late Tuesday, Feb. 14, over the quagmire created by UHIP, the state’s computerized human services benefits system.

Governor Gina Raimondo, in a press conference outside her office, said she met with Roberts “and she presented me with her resignation, which I accepted.”

“It was her choice, and I commend her for it. I think she realized, as I realized, that the challenges we’re having with UHIP require a new set of eyes, and a fresh set of eyes. “

Roberts’ top aide for many years, Jennifer Wood, who is Deputy Secretary of Health and Human Services, has been involved closely with the roll-out of the UHIP computer system and also has directed the state’s compliance effort with a 2014 federal consent decree affecting adults with developmental disabilities.

Asked whether Wood’s position is at all affected by the problems of the UHIP rollout, Raimondo’s spokesman, David Ortiz, said in an email that the Governor would give a “full update” on Wednesday.

The resignation came on the eve of a briefing Raimondo has scheduled for the media on Wednesday, Feb. 15, to discuss an analysis of UHIP conducted during the last month by her chief operating officer, Eric Beane, and steps that will be taken going forward.

“Secretary Roberts has been in public service for decades and has done so many good things for the people of Rhode Island,” Raimondo said.

In a statement, Raimondo said Roberts has “fought her entire career to expand access to affordable healthcare for more people. As my Secretary of Health and Human Services, Elizabeth played a key role in our successful efforts to drive Rhode Island’s uninsured rate to one of the lowest in the nation while reducing costs.”

Roberts was criticized by Nicholas A. Oliver of the Rhode Island Partnership for Home Care.

In a statement, he said that “Roberts’ rigid view of the state healthcare system blinded her from understanding the realities of operating healthcare practices and agencies in Rhode Island.”

“Because Roberts was a visionary stemming from her healthcare public policy interest as a state senator and a lieutenant governor without practical operational experience as a healthcare provider, her naivete and inexperience led to her ineffectiveness in the role of Secretary,” Oliver said.

Roberts’ is the third resignation connected to the $364 million computer fiasco. Melba Depena Affigne, director of the Department of Human Services, and her chief digital officer, Thom Guertin, resigned in January under pressure from Raimondo. 

Incentive Program for DD Service Providers Closer to Launch, But Lags Months Behind Court Deadline

By Gina Macris

Despite some progress, implementation still lags months behind schedule for a Rhode Island program intended to boost employment of adults with developmental disabilities.

Nor does the design of the program cover the full cost of staff training that is a prerequisite for participation, according to comments made at the monthly Employment First Task Force meeting Jan.10. The new employment supports program does reward private developmental disability service providers that already have trained staff at their own initiative.  

The General Assembly has allocated $6.8 million in the current budget for the incentive program to satisfy requirements of a 2014 federal consent decree requiring the state to boost its efforts to provide employment supports to adults with developmental disabilities.

Einloth                                                             photo by anne peters

But as the second half of the fiscal year gets underway, it appears that direct service providers have not yet been given the green light to bill for reimbursement under provisions of recently negotiated performance-based contracts, said Kim Einloth, a senior director at Perspectives Corporation.

A total of 19 contracts have been negotiated among 36 service providers operating in Rhode Island, a spokeswoman for the Executive Office of Health and Human Services said last week.

Despite an early morning snow storm Friday, Jan. 6, 18 agencies participated in a fair attended by some 40 special education high school students and another 40 young adults in the process of moving from school to adult life, according to the EOHHS spokeswoman. She anticipated the incentive program will serve about 200 adults with disabilities.

The incentive program was to have been in place Aug. 1, according to an order of the U.S. District Court.

Einloth said during the task force meeting that the director of the Community Provider Network of Rhode Island, Donna Martin, has conveyed her concerns about the program to the independent court monitor in the case, Charles Moseley.

Martin has not responded to requests for comment sent by email from Developmental Disability News.

At the task force meeting, Einloth and Kiernan O’Donnell of the Fogarty Center, another service provider, said that the program would pay a one-time bonus of up to $810 for each staff person trained to offer job-related supports, assuming that person serves ten clients.

O'Donnell          Photo by anne peters 

So-called “self-directed” families who design programs for a single individual would get only $81 to cover staff training, O’Donnell said. Neither figure fully supports an investment of 40 hours of class time and extra field work that is necessary for certification, he said, despite EOHHS assertions to the contrary. 

Claire Rosenbaum, Adult Services Coordinator at the Sherlock Center on Disabilities at Rhode Island College, said self-directed families were given four days in November to figure out whether they should apply for the program. The written materials explaining the program were so technical that parents didn’t understand them and set them aside, Rosenbaum has said. As part of her job, she has email contact with some of the self-directed families.

When the application process opened, in November, the state was unable to tell providers exactly how many bonuses they would receive under terms of the incentive program, according to Einloth, although that gap has been clarified.

According to the contracts, once staff are trained, agencies receive bonuses for completion of the course, and may bill at enhanced rates for employment-related services to new clients, Einloth and O’Donnell said in an interview after the task force meeting. .

But the billing must be done in 15-minute increments, they said, in the same fee-for-service reimbursement model that has been criticized by the U.S. Department of Justice and the court monitor as being inflexible.

Other features of the program pay one-time bonuses when clients get jobs and remain employed for 90 and 180 days. 

In the meantime, agencies do not receive enhanced rates for providing the same employment-related services to current clients – only new ones approved by the state as participants in the incentive program, O’Donnell and Einloth said. O’Donnell said agencies now routinely file appeals, one by one, to get better reimbursement for employment-related services for individual clients. O’Donnell said he understands most of those appeals are granted.

The new incentive program appears to draw attention away from the fact that reimbursement rates are too low across the board for providers to do their jobs, O’Donnell said.

He and Einloth also are co-presidents of the Rhode Island Association of People Supporting Employment First, a professional organization.

Meanwhile, a task force member with developmental disabilities, Andrew Whalen, told his colleagues that he had received a letter a day earlier, on Jan.9, notifying him he is eligible for services from BHDDH. Whalen applied nearly a year ago, after the death of his mother in January, 2016.

He first mentioned the long wait for a decision at last month's meeting of the task force, when the discussion touched on the state’s efforts to render speedy eligibility decisions and the effect of continuing human services computer problems on services for adults with developmental disabilities.

.In December, Whalen also said the new computer system – called UHIP – deleted a separate application for food stamps that he had filed. At the most recent task force meeting, he said his application was “on hold” because, thanks to his generosity of his sister, the balance in his checking account was too high. 

Kevin Nerney, chairman of the task force, said that Whalen could solve the problem by moving the excess money to an ABLE account. ABLE, which stands for Achieving a Better Life Experience, is a new type of savings account authorized by Congress and the General Assembly that allows individuals with disabilities to set aside money without compromising their Social Security or Medicaid benefits.

Nerney said ABLE began accepting applications from Rhode Islanders only in recent days at https://savewithable.com Paper applications will be available in March, he said.  

New UHIP Computer in RI Seems to Undermine Court-Ordered Timely Benefits For DD Population

By Gina Macris

andrew whalen                                                  all photos by anne peters

Andrew Whalen, a 31 year-old Rhode Islander on the autism spectrum, applied for support services in the wake of his mother’s death in January. He’s still waiting to hear whether he is eligible.

When a psychologist interviewed him Nov. 16, she said the state’s Division of Developmental Disabilities was backed up addressing cases involved in a federal consent decree and that his application was “not an emergency,” Whalen said.

Last week, one of his sisters took him to the Department of Human Services (DHS) to check on the separate application he filed two months ago for food stamps. He said he learned that the state’s new $364 million computer system had deleted his records and the only way he could remedy the problem was to file for benefits all over again. 

Whalen represents adults with developmental disabilities on the Employment First Task Force, created by a 2014 federal consent decree as a bridge between the state and the community as Rhode Island moves to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Under terms of the consent decree, Rhode Island must move away from segregated sheltered workshops and day programs toward supported employment in the community and integrated non-work activities over a ten-year period.

Whalen explained his plight Tuesday, Dec. 13, to his colleagues on the task force at a meeting in Warwick, and to the federal court monitor in the consent decree case, who was listening via conference call.

The monitor, Charles Moseley, wanted to know how many applicants for adult developmental disability services might be affected by the computerized Unified Health Infrastructure Project. UHIP, as it is known, is supposed to process all the state’s social service benefits, including the Medicaid money used for developmental disability services.

Sue Donovan of the Rhode Island Parent Information Network (RIPIN) ventured an estimate – about 100 – but asked Moseley to confirm figures with the state. 

RIPIN works with families of high school students with developmental disabilities who are making the transition to adult services. Donovan said she knows of one person who was authorized by BHDDH to start receiving developmental disability supports September 1, but the Medicaid funding didn’t actually didn’t actually clear UHIP until Monday, Dec. 12.

Donovan said there are 23 young adults who have been deemed eligible for developmental disability services who are waiting for their funding to come through. 

In addition, about 83 young people are expected to be found eligible and are “heading for the same problem,” she said.

“I’m sure the Division (of Developmental Disabilities) has a better idea of those numbers,” Donovan said.

“I will look into that,” Moseley said.

“It’s a shame. It’s a disgrace,” Donovan said of the situation.

State Says It Is Monitoring Flow of DD Benefits

On Wednesday, Dec.14, a spokeswoman for Jennifer Wood, Deputy Secretary of Health and Human Services, said that “we are individually monitoring the services received by every DD (developmental disabilities) client who has been determined eligible for Medicaid services to ensure that their Medicaid coverage is working correctly."  She did not offer any figures on those who might be affected by the UHIP problems.

“BHDDH social workers are also always available to their clients if they are experiencing any issues with any of the benefits they are receiving,” the spokeswoman said.

Developmental disability officials have publicly acknowledged in recent months that even without a crisis like UHIP, social workers have a hard time keeping up with the needs of clients in their care. The average caseload for each social worker is 205, according to Jane Gallivan, a developmental disabilities consultant to the state.

Rhode Island has been under a federal court order to see to it that individuals with developmental disabilities receive eligibility decisions and begin services in a timely manner after they complete high school.

In response to the order, the state Department of Behavioral Healthcare, Developmental Disabilities and Hospitals (BHDDH) has said that at the end of September, it cleared a backlog of applications that earlier in the year had numbered about 250.

BHSSH also established strict timelines for responding to applicants going forward, determining within 30 days whether they were eligible, needed to submit additional written information, or needed to schedule an interview. 

Whalen’s experience – he waited 10 months to be interviewed by the psychologist – raises new questions about how strictly BHDDH is following its new eligibility timelines, not only for high school students moving to adult services, but for applicants of all ages and circumstances. 

If BHDDH isn’t meeting its timelines because of UHIP, Donovan said, maybe the judge in the consent decree case, John J. McConnell, Jr. of U.S. District Court, can do something to “help move the state to get this DHS system corrected.”

Wood’s spokeswoman declined to address Whalen’s situation publicly, citing confidentiality laws. She insisted that BHDDH is working within court-approved time frames to determine eligibility.

The American Civil Liberties Union has filed its own class action lawsuit against the state in U.S. District Court in the last week over the UHIP troubles with a focus on the food stamp program, saying the denial of benefits puts thousands of households “at imminent risk of going hungry as a result of being denied needed assistance to help them feed their families.”

Bandusky

Ray Bandusky, executive director of the Rhode Island Disability Law Center, told task force members Tuesday that Anne Mulready, one of the center’s managing attorneys, and Linda Katz of the Economic Progress Institute, have met with Governor Gina Raimondo to emphasize the effect the computer problems are having on poor and disabled people.

One of the main points Mulready made, according to Bandusky, was that “the kind of people who need assistance are not going to go online” to fill out a form.

Last week, Raimondo acknowledged that it was a mistake for the human services department to lay off 15 workers and transfer another 30 to the Department of Children, Youth and Families (DCYF) just before it rolled out the new online application process. She has ordered the agency to hire 35 temporary workers to address thousands of applications that are in limbo.

At the task force meeting, Claire Rosenbaum of the Sherlock Center on Disabilities at Rhode Island College said that some of the workers who got “bumped” to DCYF had many years’ experience in resolving the very problems that DHS now faces. That expertise is gone, she said.

Deb Kney, director of Advocates in Action, said that in Whalen’s case, “It took him a couple of months just to be told he had to start over” in the food stamp application process. Advocates in Action employs Whalen to help empower others with developmental disabilities to become advocates for themselves.

A parent on the task force, Mary Beth Cournoyer, said she knows a mother whose son has been found eligible for developmental disability services but who has been “sitting at home for a year” because his family cannot find providers.

After Whelan recounted his problems, Kiernan O’Donnell of the Fogarty Center, a service provider, remarked that “a lot of people focus on transition (to adult services) but people in their twenties, thirties and forties are being marginalized.”

At the same time, he said, providers are still hearing stories of social workers telling clients of  retirement age- in one case an 85 year-old man – that they must seek employment to continue to receive developmental disability services.

O'Donnell said the state's resources would be better spent helping the many individuals who want to find jobs.  

The state’s consent decree coordinator, Mary Madden, has said publicly that no one will force individuals to work. 

Concerns Expressed About Supported Employment Incentives

To satisfy the federal court, BHDDH is planning to roll out a supported employment incentive program in the new year, with a provider fair January 6 that is intended to help individuals seeking employment connect with support services.

The incentive program is funded by $6.8 million for the current fiscal year, but none of it has been spent. 

McConnell, the consent decree judge, had ordered the state to implement a supported employment incentive program by Aug. 1.

Twenty three agencies have applied to provide supported employment services eligible for the incentives, according to Donna Martin, executive director of the Community Provider Network of Rhode Island.

Martin, O’Donnell, and Kim Einloth of Perspectives, another provider, all expressed major concerns about a Catch-22 in the incentive program.  

Einloth said private service providers don’t have the resources to hire new staff and train them to provide supported employment services, but the state’s incentives are bonuses that would not kick in until certain incremental goals were met.

Kim Einloth

For example, Einloth said, the one-time bonus for training a supported employment specialist, $810, does not cover the cost of the training. 

The program is “not sustainable,” she said.

Einloth questioned whether the providers who attend the fair in January will be ready to present themselves to new clients. 

O’Donnell said, “I wonder if they are satisfied with commitment to people they already have,”

Martin replied, “You are spot-on with that, Kie.”

O’Donnell and Einloth, members of the task force, also are co-presidents of the Rhode Island Chapter of the Association of People Supporting Employment First (RIAPSE), which promotes “real jobs at real wages” for individuals with disabilities.

Claire Rosenbaum

Rosenbaum, of the Sherlock Center, offered the perspective of so-called self-directed families, who organize individualized support services for only one person.

While an agency might get $810 after it trains a job developer on the assumption the developer works with ten clients, the family would only get $81, she said.

Because agencies routinely turn away new clients, self-direction has become the only option for many families who otherwise might not choose that route.

Rosenbaum said the advisory sent by BHDDH to providers about applying for the incentive program did not reach all self-directed families, and those who did receive it found it so technical that they couldn’t understand it and set it aside.

Einloth said the self-directed families are not alone. Even for professionals in the field, “it’s been a rocky road trying to understand the plan, because it’s changed so many times.”

The state had a proposed contract for provider agencies, but the contract was “pulled” last week, Einloth said. Nevertheless, a training session for providers on how to submit bills for the reimbursement program will move forward next week, she said.

BHDDH has indicated some money could be available to defray start-up costs, but has never defined that amount, Einloth said.

Martin said she was disheartened that the $6.8 million allocated by the General Assembly for supported employment  remains out of the reach of providers who could deliver results.

Moseley asked Martin to follow up in a separate conversation.

Over the phone, he said he saw “a lot of work” ahead.

Wood’s spokeswoman said Wednesday that it is important to note that the monitor and U.S. Department of Justice approved the supported employment incentive program. .

“We are committed to maintaining an open dialogue and partnership with the provider community moving forward,” said the spokeswoman, Sophie O’Connell.

“As always, we encourage providers and others to share concerns and feedback directly with us so we can work together to address them,” O’Connell said.

(This article has been updated to reflect the fact that the supported employment incentive program passed the review of the court monitor and the DOJ.)